Roselyn Perez
October 28, 2026
Why people are choosing AI over humans — and what it means for human connection

The thing that makes us irreplaceable isn’t what we can do. It’s whether the person in front of us feels seen.
I want to talk about something a little controversial today: AI.
There’s so much out there about it. Is it going to replace humans? Cost people their jobs? Be good for everyone? Who knows. There’s no shortage of opinions. But I want to focus on one piece of it in particular — AI and human connection.
Because this is the area where most people feel certain. Surely connection, love, being seen, feeling we belong — surely that’s something only a human can give or receive. And research shows that’s not entirely true.
When people choose AI over a human
A 2023 study in JAMA Internal Medicine had people interact with chatbots like ChatGPT, and with other humans. And across many areas of the study, people kept choosing the AI.
But here’s what stood out about why. The thing that made them prefer the chatbot was a perception that it was more empathetic than the human.
Empathy. That was the deciding factor in people choosing AI over a person. And that should make us stop and reflect.
The second study changed the picture
Then there’s another one, run between 2024 and 2025, called “the illusion of empathy.” Same setup — people interacted with AI and had live interactions with other humans. But this time, when they perceived the human in front of them as more empathetic, more open, less judgmental, they chose the human.
And something else happened: their level of fulfillment was higher. They could feel the difference. With a chatbot, there was a hesitation — I’m not so sure this is really what I want. With a genuinely empathetic human, there wasn’t.
So put those two together. People will choose AI when the human in front of them doesn’t come across as empathetic and understanding and non-judgmental. And they’ll choose the human, and feel more fulfilled, when the human does.
What AI doesn’t have
Why does this matter so much right now? Because everyone knows AI is here to stay. It’s not going anywhere, and it’s been genuinely useful — for corporations, for organizations, for entrepreneurs like me — in handling tasks that were often the ones we didn’t want to do anyway.
But that leaves us with the things that are ours as humans. So what sets us apart?
ChatGPT and other AI tools don’t have a nervous system the way we do. They don’t have mirror neurons. For anyone who hasn’t come across that term, mirror neurons are the ones in charge of detecting and feeling social cues. When someone frowns, you can feel it. When someone smiles, you’re influenced by that smile. AI doesn’t have that. No nervous system, no neurological process.
What it does have, because of all the information it’s trained on, is a very skilled understanding of what makes a human feel good. So it can absolutely be empathetic. But it only wins in the moments when the human interaction isn’t being perceived as empathetic, understanding, and non-judgmental.
Where that leaves us
So where does that leave us? In territory we maybe haven’t been challenged in as much before.
Because a lot of what used to hold us together — in workplaces, sometimes even in relationships — was just doing the things that needed doing. We weren’t necessarily happy, but, well, no one gets to be happy. That kind of rhetoric patches over so many missed chances to truly connect — intimately, emotionally, empathetically — with other people, even at work.
And here’s an interesting piece: other research shows that across Gen Z, Millennials, and Baby Boomers, they all value a workplace and relationships where they feel seen, where there’s flexibility. So this is becoming a standard for organizations. It’s not going to be negotiable. It can’t be. Because when something else is handling the most practical work, the question becomes — what’s left for us to embrace?
I’ll be honest, this research doesn’t make me feel threatened. It excites me. It confirms how much emotional intelligence and social intelligence matter in this era, and how they can no longer be waved off as optional, as nice-to-have. We’re moving into a time when emotions are a huge part of what we have to account for, in our interactions with others and with ourselves.
I remember listening to Brené Brown in one of her talks, saying that organizations today may be guided by all kinds of values, but the value that’s going to be pivotal in the future, in every area of being human, including work, is the heart. The emotions.
What being empathetic doesn’t mean
This was going to be a short one, so let me leave you with the reflection.
How are you connecting with others today? How are you interacting day to day — not only with other people, but with yourself? Because empathy, compassion, kindness, tolerance are going to become pivotal, completely necessary for us to thrive in a world where everything else is taken care of. Where what’s left is to see each other. To truly see one another from a place of value, even in disagreement. Even when you disagree, from the simple principle of remembering that the person in front of you is a human being, and choosing to see them with compassion and respect, even if you have to set boundaries. That’s a whole other topic, and I’ve talked about boundaries before — but boundaries built from a place of compassion. Those are the stronger ones, because they foster connection.
Being compassionate and empathetic with others doesn’t mean they get to step over you, or that they get closer access to you. It’s the opposite. When you see others from a place of unconditional love, regardless of what they’ve done, you get to live in that state. And from that state, you have the discernment to decide whether you want it disrupted.
Think of it this way. You go to a spa. You know that freeing feeling. And then someone comes to you with a worry or a concern, and you can see so clearly that it isn’t the emergency it’s being presented as. Because you’re clear — in your body and in your state of mind. I’m relaxed. I’m calm. And what’s in front of me doesn’t carry the urgency it’s claiming. And that’s okay. You can be empathetic and still set the boundary of whether you want to take something on in that moment or not.
That’s exactly how it translates into relationships and workplaces, especially in situations where you don’t get to choose the people — coworkers, and family too. We often don’t choose our family. But when you choose the state of empathy and connection first, you’re honoring yourself, your sovereign self. And you’re honoring them. Without ever sacrificing your boundaries.
This is what we’re left with, once so much of life is handled for us. Picture going back in time and telling someone from the medieval era that there’s a thing called a phone, and you can place an order and food arrives at your door, no hunting required. They’d look at you like you were out of your mind. Our lives, as stressful and complicated as they can feel, have been made easier in so many ways. And what that frees us for is each other.
So how are you connecting — with others, and with yourself — today?
— Roselyn Pérez Casiano
Brain-science nerd, former LCSW, proud Latina, keynote speaker, and coach for ambitious women
get to know me
BEfore you get any further
After 15 years as a therapist, I hit a career high while my personal life was falling apart. On the brink of a divorce, I realized how easy it is for high-achieving women to succeed on paper while silently unraveling.
So I used the very tools I gave my clients to rebuild my marriage and redefine what success meant to me. Now, I support other women in redefining what wealth and success means for them beyond the constant push and quiet burnout. Through practical tools rooted in neuroscience and real-world application, I help women reconnect with their deepest goals and create lives that actually feel good.
Be the first to comment